I agree with your comment, it is strange how the writer makes you pick sides because some people really dont like to choose what the outcome of an event is.
Monday, November 29, 2010
Piano Lesson #7
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Piano Lesson 6
This section of The Piano Lesson was pretty interesting because it shows that Berniece is a lot like Boy Willie in that she doesn't really care about what Avery is telling her and that she is selfish. He keeps telling her that she needs to let go of the past and Crawley and the piano but she just doesn't listen. The theme that "The Past is Present" is true in that history repeats itself but it can also be misleading because if you dwell on to the things of the past for too long, sometimes they will cause you to get distracted by other things that are more important in the present.
Andrew S said...
Andrew S said...
i think that avery will end up marrying berniece because he said that he was going to bless the house and then that will probably get berniece to stop worrying so much about the past and then just marry him.
Monday, November 22, 2010
Piano Lesson 5
When Mrs. Wecker warned us that there would be some inappropriate language in The Piano Lesson, I didn't really think much of it and I kind of thought that it would just be little petty words but it turns out that the way they talk can be pretty crude at times. The use of the word "nigger" is used throughout the book and euphemisms, such as when Wining Boy is instructing Lymon how to pick up women. It makes the book kind of awkward to read in class but I like it better that Cry because I can keep up with it better.
Andrew S said to Michelle Vollmuller...
Yeah the first time I heard them talk about the ghost, I thought it would just be some unimportant thing that just happened... I didn't think that the ghosts would come up again and keep getting talked about.
Piano Lesson 4
When we were reading the piano lesson I was thinking about why there were so many ghosts and other things being talked about. There are the the ghost of the yellow dog and then there is sutter's ghost. I think that maybe the two are connected somehow, whether sutter is one of the yellow dogs or something else, I don't know. Something may happen later on in the book explaining more about them.
It seems like there is alot of talk about ghosts in the book, maybe they have something to do with what will happen later
It seems like there is alot of talk about ghosts in the book, maybe they have something to do with what will happen later
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Piano Lesson 3
When they started singing I wasn't surprised because I knew that music would somehow come into the book one way or another and this is the first major part when they do anything musical. They all seem to get together pretty well when they are singing and they stop arguing for the first time in, well, ever. I am starting to wonder when the piano lesson is going to happen and between who. Also since the book is only called The Piano Lesson, is there only going to be one or more? I'm also thinking that Wining Boy is somehow going to be involved with the piano lesson.
Andrew S said to Alec...
The music does seem like it is a connector to all the characters because they all join in and they all know the song.
Wednesday, November 17, 2010
The Piano Lesson 2
The Piano Lesson is turning out to seem pretty fast paced and more fun to read because you can kind of tell what kind of voice to use when saying your part because of the dialogue they use. One thing about it that is kind of frustrating is that they seem to stay on the same topic for like four or five pages, just talking about watermelons and the piano or some other thing. One of the things I tabbed was that Boy Willie didn't really care about Avery's dream even though he was the one who asked about it. The reason I think that he didn't really care was that he immediately changed the subject after she was done telling about the dream. He seems just really selfish and narcissistic and he also mentioned that he wanted to be a preacher so people would call him "Reverend Boy Willie".
Andrew S said to Olivia C...
Yeah I also noticed that he was really selfish. After Avery's long story about her dream, Boy Willie changes the subject and immediately goes back to talking about selling watermelons or the piano or something (can't remember which).
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Piano Lesson 1
When we were reading in class, I thought, "wow, all of these people sound like complete rednecks in the way that they talk," and I turned out to be right as we read on. The language that they all use make them sound like they are from the south. The writer uses slang and crude wording to portray the setting and each persons character.
Andrew S said...
Yeah, it does seem like an earlier time period because of the language they use and I also thought that it would start out just being about music and such but i was wrong..... horribly wrong.
Tuesday, November 2, 2010
Cry journal 9
The first thing i tabbed was when he said "the lawyer told him,in gentle and compassionate words, that there would be no mercy" because it is just another one of those parts where Kumalo's hopes get crushed by bad news.
"When he had finished he went out to look at the clouds, for it was exciting to see them after weeks of pitiless sun" (275). I tabbed this because I remember analyzing a sentence from somewhere in the book that called it a "pitiless sun". Paton is repeating the phrase because it gives a good image of what the conditions are for Kumalo.
"When he had finished he went out to look at the clouds, for it was exciting to see them after weeks of pitiless sun" (275). I tabbed this because I remember analyzing a sentence from somewhere in the book that called it a "pitiless sun". Paton is repeating the phrase because it gives a good image of what the conditions are for Kumalo.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)